D.N.A. controversy – Netaji Mystery ( Part-1)

Proposition of D.N.A. test on the human ashes, kept in Renkoji temple, Tokyo, allegedly of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, is a carefully made criminal design, to cover up the truth behind Netaji mystery.

Transfer of wealth from INA (Indian National Army) fund / Bank to a secret account in Overseas Bank in the name of Jawaharlal Nehru is possibly the first source of black money in the hands of Nehru – Gandhi dynasty. This dynasty, in collaborations with its foreign masters for common interest, is trying to cover up the facts in Netaji mystery. Under pressure of circumstances, Nehru constituted Sah Nawaz Khan Committee to investigate the mystery (1956), Nehru from behind the curtain, could successfully manipulate the progress of the activity of the committee. It could not / did not go to Taihoku, Taiwan, the place of alleged accident. It was not constituted under the commission of inquiry act 1952. Committee submitted a doctored report. Suresh Chandra Bose submitted a dissentient report, which was not accepted by the G.O.I. In 1956, Taiwan Government submitted one report, on this subject, telling that there is no record of any Plane accident on alleged day of 18 August, 1945 in Taihoku airport (alleged airport) and there is no definite proof of Netaji’s actual death at that time. Copies of this report were submitted to government of UK and government of India in 1956. Government of UK declassified this file in UK in 1971 and government of India never disclosed the receipt of such report from Taiwan government. In December 1969 a group of MPs, after their tour to Taiwan, & South East Asia submitted one resolution to PMO, telling that government of Taiwan has told them that there was no plane crash on 18 August, 1945 in Taihoku airport. Series of events around that the time put Mrs Indira Gandhi to situation compulsions, where she constituted Justice Khosla Commission to investigate the mystery. But again Justice Khosla was being guided from behind. On the surface, he went to Taiwan, but did not go to the alleged place of accident, place of cremation or concerned records office or any government office for necessary documents. Again he submitted one manufactured report to satisfy the interest of Nehru Gandhi dynasty. Weaponised with these reports of Shah Nawaz Khan Committee and Justice Khosla Commission report, congress government in 1992, proceeded to confer the award of posthumous ‘Bharat Ratna’ to Netaji – apparently to honour him, but actually it was a carefully designed cunning process to establish that Netaji actually died in alleged plane crash. Naturally some patriotic citizens of India filed one PIL (public interest litigation) case in Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta, against the notification by government of India. Smelling an impending defeat government of India, by appeal took the case to Hon’ble Supreme Court of India where government of India hoped to manipulate victory in this case. Armaments of Shah Khan Committee & Justice Khosla Commission reports, money power, political manipulations could not procure victory for government of India in this case.

By Supreme Court order, government of India’s notification of awarding ‘posthumous Bharat Ratna’ was cancelled in the year 1997iIn 1998, Kolkata High Court, in verdict in a PIL case against government of India, ordered the institution of a fresh commission to investigate into Netaji Mystery.

In 1999 government of India notified the institution of Justice Mukherjee Commission of Inquiry, headed by Retd. Supreme court Justice M.K. Mukherjee chosen by the then CJI (Chief Justice of India).

In 2005, Justice Mukherjee Commission report was submitted to government of India. This report, along many things, has clearly told that : (1) There is no plane crash on 18 August, 1945 in Taihoku. (2) There is no proof of Netaji’s death and cremation there. (3) The alleged ashes, kept in Renkoji Temple, Tokyo, are therefore, not of NetajiSubhas Chandra Bose.

In the volumes of the report, contains opinions of DNA and Forensic Science experts from India, Japan, Germany, UK, USA which clearly tell that from end product of cremated human body, identifiable DNA materials can not be obtained for logical conclusions. On the contrary, one news of DNA testing of the alleged ashes, kept in Renkoji Temple is being circulated in printing and visual media, funded by interested circles – as if DNA test of human ash (end product of cremated human body), is prescribed by Science journals and text books. Very carefully and cunningly those medias and other elements are confusing in people’s mind – the process of burning vis. Cremation and composition of human ash vis. Human remains.

Dozens of witnesses in both Shah Nawaz Khan Committee and Khosla Commission have deposed that the alleged body was cremated and ashes were preserved. The urn containing this ‘Ashes’ was inspected by experts in 1945-1946. as per report in CSDIC File – INA / 273.(1946) experts could not see any identifiable burnt human bones and they even opined that “but ashes don’t prove who the dead man is, they might be any body’s or they may not be those of a human being at all”. …. In 1989 the Renkoji Temple was burnt into ashes by a devastating fire. Then appeared a new specimen in urn which shows – big human partially burnt body – bones of skull, hip and long bones of a human being – who has been partially cremated / burnt.

This clearly shows that the specimen of 1945-46 has been fudged / manipulated. This is a criminal violation of laws of specimen preservation. This is a criminal design to suit the interest of the dynasty’s / persons who want to prove that Netaji died in the plane crash. This group wants to circumvent the primary fact that there was no plane crash in August 1945 in Taihoku airport, Taiwan. This is a criminal design – criminality in confusing the people’s mind, manipulation or fudging the specimen for perjury, of violation of process of natural justice. This is also against all logical human thinking, against science, against forensic science. As a nation with minimum quantum and quality of intellect we must come forward to protest against this finely, carefully crafted criminal design against all values, laws, logic and science.

Human ashes do not contain identifiable DNA. If specimen is fudged / manipulated some DNA may be available, but this will never indicate the person. In maximum, it can indicate a dynasty. Most possibly, some body parts of the dynasty concerned has been used for fudging here to suit the criminal interest. The evidence of the fact of no plane crash is primary and confirmatory, on the contrary DNA test is always circumstantial and only a corroborative evidence.

Dr M S PAL
mspalmch@yahoo.co.in
MBBS (Cal), MS (General Surgery),M.Ch (Cardio Thoracic Surgery).
Associate Proffesor, Cardio Thoracic Surgery, Medical College, Kolkata.
Deponent and Witness in Hon’ble Justice Manoj Mukherjee Commission of Inquiry(’99-‘05)

Some Old But Important Articles

Khan Abdur Gaffar Khan's Statement

Mysterious Lady's Sensational Confession

Black Box Of History On 12th June ’2010

Country Must Know What Happend To Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose

A Special  Screening of the Documentary Film “Black Box Of History” Directed By Amlan Kusum Ghose on Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose has been organised on 12th June ’2010, Saturday at 2 pm in Rabindra Bhavan, Asansol, West Bengal.

Panelists of Screening Dr. Pabitra Kumar Gupta (Former vice chancellor) Prof. Nando Chakraborty (Presidency Collage) Dr. Madhu Sudan Pal, (Head of the Cardiology Department Medical Collage) Sh.Bijoy Nag, (editor Jayshree) and Amlan Kusum Ghose (Director Of The Documentary – Black Box Of History).

Entry For Free.

The rabbit hole of Netaji mystery

As of today, the Netaji mystery maze has only two ways out. One leads to Russia, and the other to Faizabad. This I am stating with some knowledge of the issues involved. Inclusive of the myriad Netaji turned sadhu baba tales.

The point is, on scrutiny the entire gamut of theories vanish leaving only the aforementioned two premises. One can say whatever one wishes to — Netaji was in Guna, Dehradun, Sheopurkalan, or he was killed in the Red Fort — but without some backup evidence nothing is going to pass muster.

As things stand now, the seminal findings of the Mukherjee Commission will require to be worked upon to bring about an end to the controversy. It has been confirmed that Netaji flew towards the USSR even as his friends in the Imperial Japanese Army cooked up the news of his death. This begs the question: What happened to Netaji in the USSR? Right now there is nothing to conclusively prove that he was even there. Our Government isn’t interested; they formed an opinion long ago that Bose had died in Taiwan.

The Russians have given some inadequate information to them on the lines that Bose never came to the USSR in 1945 and afterwards. (An attempt by my friends and I to access the complete information under the RTI has not succeeded.) All we are left with are some intelligence and other reports saying Bose was in the USSR. Those bits might help one to form some belief or make further inquiries, which won’t be possible without the Government’s assistance.

Many people think that Netaji never got out of the USSR. They allege that he was kept a prisoner in a Siberian gulag and subsequently liquidated sometime during the Stalin era. Stalin butchered millions of his own people, he was not expected to show any affection to Subhas — the logic goes. Researcher VP Saini, who wrote a book titled ‘Conspirators, Abductors and Killers of Netaji?’ publicly says that former Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru was tacitly responsible for Netaji’s fate. Noted Russia expert Dr Purabi Roy is of the similar opinion. Personally, I have not come across anything credible to suggest that Bose was eliminated in the USSR.

The fascinating tale of Bhagwanji is on the other end of spectrum. Its preposterous outlook makes it repulsive to most people. Anyhow, for a variety of reasons, including a report given by India’s top handwriting expert, this case has something to stand on. But more investigation is required to arrive at a conclusion about Bhagwanji’s identity. This is taking into account Mukherjee Commission’s disapproval of the Bhagwanji angle “in absence of any clinching evidence”. That is, there was some evidence, but not enough. For instance, let’s see this passage from the report:

“Apparently, there is no reason for not acting or relying upon the evidence of the last two categories of witnesses particularly of the category who had seen Netaji before 1945 and also met Bhagwanji/Gumnami Baba face to face on a number of occasions, more so when their evidence regarding the frequent visits of some freedom fighters, eminent politicians and former members of INA on January 23 and during the Durga Puja festival is supported by the fact that letters written by some of them including Prof Samar Guha, Dr Pabitra Mohan Roy and Ms Leela Roy were found in `Rambhawan’.”

But, as the report noted, “there are other formidable facts and circumstances on record which stand in the way of this Commission in arriving at a conclusive finding that Bhagwanji/Gumnami Baba was none other than Netaji”.

As I see them, those facts and circumstances are:

1. The passing away of Bhagwanji’s front-ranking associates who could have given unimpeachable evidence.

2. Absence of any photographic evidence.

3. Negative results thrown up by forensic tests performed by governmental labs on Bhagwanji’s handwritings and some teeth believed to be his.

As regards point 3, no reliance can be placed on the judgment drawn on the Netaji disappearance case by any individuals or institutions linked to the Government of India. The Government’s apparent aim is to hush up the matter and if anyone is willing to buy the word of their labs on Bhagwanji DNA test, etc, they should also go along with the Government’s version that Netaji died in Taiwan. I hear the believers in the Russia angle coming up with inconsistent arguments. They won’t believe the Government side when it comes to Russia, but will believe them on Bhagwanji. They can’t have a pick and choose policy to suit their thoughts.

I fear if the Renkoji ashes, or for that matter some pieces of bone china crockery, are tested for DNA matching here in India, they will be proven to be Netaji’s remains. If I have formed such a negative opinion about my own government, it is only after coming across their misdeeds over this case. Those who have openly obstructed the justice can go to any extent to keep things under wraps.

It is in this background that I’d like you to consider the following hypotheses, rather allegations, purporting to offer further insight into the Netaji mystery. They are to the effect that:

1. Our Government has been aware as to what happened to Netaji. They left him to rot in Stalin’s Russia.

2. The sadhu baba stories were planted by the Government with the twin purpose of diluting the Russian angle and trivilising the entire issue.

3. The game started in early 1960s with Shoulmari baba. BN Mullick, the famed Director of Intelligence Bureau and Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru’s right hand man, was behind it.

I am led to believe that our Government does have a good idea about the case. Two, there was something fishy about the sadhu of Shoulmari. The fellow who was said to be the administrator of the Shoulmari ashram was possibly an Intelligence Bureau officer.

And, I can’t help notice that the propagators of Shoulmari and other babas evidently had no insight into Netaji’s disappearance from Saigon. While countering the plane crash theory, which they had to, these people lifted arguments of Professor Samar Guha, who used to frequent Bhagwanji. Shoulmari and other babas also skipped the Russian angle, which I think is a reality so far as Netaji’s going there is concerned.

Bhagwanji called the Shoulmari subterfuge a “parallel bluff” and talked about “his” escaping to the USSR via Diren in Manchuria after a “concocted air crash”. He made an allegation about a top Azad Hind Government Minister – which rings true if we look at still classified records. It was rather intriguing for a holy man to talk about the functioning of prisons camps in Siberia. He gave out more details which appear to be the reasons why could not come out. One gets goose pimples thinking should they turn out to be true.

I fail to understand one thing: If indeed Netaji had been killed in the USSR in early 1950s, and some agency set up fake babas early 1960s onwards, what purpose would it have served? Why would the Government, which allegedly had things to hide, would shoot itself in foot by starting off a frenzy over a dead issue? What did Bhagwanji mean by “parallel bluff”? Why was the Central Intelligence Agency of America receiving dope on Subhas Bose as late as 1964? Didn’t those guys had better things to do?!

Some of the arguments made before Khosla Commission were hair-raising. It was charged that the Intelligence Bureau, a bugbear in those days, was on a lookout for information related to Bose. I remember one statement verbatim: “When the Government of India has accepted Shah Nawaz Committee’s report that Netaji is dead then how is it that the Intelligence Department goes after every news when it appears that Netaji is not dead and he is alive?”

All this (which is only a fraction of the facts I have collated in my book) call for some investigation if the people of this country think that the ambit of justice and truth also includes the case of Bose, as it does that of Jessica Lall. Such an investigation will have to be undertaken in the right earnest by our Government taking the public in full confidence. But as a prerequisite, they will do well to release all the information they, and their intelligence agencies, are sitting on. Then, they could take up the matter with the Russian Government at the highest level. They can always take a leaf out of Swedes’ book. After a decade of dogged pursuit, they managed to get the truth about Raoul Wallenberg out from the Russians. We won’t to wait that long. The Russians are our friends, and our Prime Minister is an admirer of Netaji.

The truth is out there. We can get to it by taking the issue head on, not by turning our backs on it. The starting point is Russia. The endgame could be in Russia or Faizabad. This is the point we have reached in the veritable rabbit hole of India’s biggest cover-up.

Anuj Dhar | Author: Back from Dead: Inside the Subhas Bose Mystery

Source: Facebook